2. Cute outfits? Thanks to Simon, TV will never be the same. They join the judging panel alongside Simon Cowell and Cheryl Fernandez-Versini, who is back for her fifth series. Despite an excellent host in Cat Deeley, Fox's "So You Think You Can Dance" doesn't have a great track record with judges. Chrissy Teigen Is Breaking The Stigma Around Baby Loss And Miscarriage, So Why Are People Reacting So Horribly? Rita Ora and Nick Grimshaw were confirmed as new judges on The X Factor last month, replacing Mel B and Louis Walsh. Dannii Minogue must be one of The X Factor’s best-loved judges. The "Runway" judges have never been overly kind, but Kors had a way with snappy, almost cruel one-liners in a way that no one else on the series has. 'So You Think You Can Dance,' Seasons 3-5, 8-11: Nigel Lythgoe and Mary Murphy.

1. A Coca-Cola cup? Let us not forget Arlene Phillips, who lit up the Strictly Come Dancing judging panel for six years before she was unceremoniously dumped by the BBC in favour of Alesha, who was 36 years younger than the 66-year-old dancer. Like us on Facebook to see similar stories, Covid crisis could force extra 2.5m girls into child marriage – charity, EastEnders star Max Bowden reveals heartbreak as grandfather loses battle with cancer, My Race Made Me Stand Out In The Fashion Industry, So I Refused To Dress To Fit In, Champions League 2020-21: Teams, groups, fixtures, results & everything you need to know, Number of people working from home in UK rises following government U-turn, Apple kills the last iPod nano, as music player is officially marked as 'vintage'.

'American Idol,' Season 9: Simon Cowell, Ellen DeGeneres, Randy Jackson and Kara DioGuardi. One of the most earnest reality TV judges, he guided Andrea Begley totriumph in series two. Some reality show judges like Tyra Banks, have been the judges for over 20 consecutive seasons of a show.

Reuniting Abdul and Cowell seemed like a brilliant idea, but was a forced recreation of the glory days of "Idol." It's a testament to the brilliance of the concept behind Fox's "Masked Singer" that the series has seen so much success in spite of its downright terrible judging panel. Scherzinger, a member of the two worst judging panels ever, joined after Cheryl Cole was unceremoniously dismissed after two episodes. There was no chemistry here, but at least things improved when Demi Lovato and Britney Spears joined in Season 2. Commenting is not currently available, but don’t worry! Piers Morgan’s first foray into reality TV came in 2006 when Simon Cowell needed a replacement for himself on America’s Got Talent. Here's your chance to vote for the best reality show judge. Louis has flown the coop (finally, after 11 long years) and Mel B's stint has already come to an end.And let's not forget Dermot himself is moving on.

There are plenty of reality TV judges to choose from so select the judges who you think should sit atop this Ultimate List. Niceness? 1. Of course, reality TV judges don’t get much better than Simon Cowell. 1. Season 12's brilliant panel balanced the personalities perfectly and had so much chemistry that Shelton and Stefani began a highly publicized romance. Reality Tv Judges. 'American Idol,' Seasons 1-7: Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson. 5. Would the American superstar be willing to devote time to his protégés? The Black Eyed Peas star helped Jermain Jackman win in series three, and has been one of the funniest judges to boot. After Abdul left "Idol," Fox never found anyone to mesh with Cowell and Jackson, but the biggest failure was Season 9, in which DeGeneres's niceness clashed with Cowell's vitriol. Workmen surround Kia with 6ft metal fences, Turkey and Poland removed from travel corridors and added to quarantine list, Arrest made after two men found shot dead in car at industrial estate, Princess Alexandra's granddaughter Flora Ogilvy marries at private London wedding, Princess Eugenie just dressed her bump in the most beautiful floral dress, Man City Champions League draw: Pep Guardiola’s side learn 2020 group stage opponents, Tesco begins ‘new chapter’ as Ken Murphy takes over as boss, iPhone SE (2020) deals for October 2020: SIM-free price and contract deals for the cheap iPhone, Dr Miriam Stoppard: Prevention is better than cure when it comes to insect bites, Champion jockey Oisin Murphy denies taking cocaine after failed drugs test at Chantilly, Inside the Irish castle used for The Last Duel filming with Matt Damon and Jodie Comer, McDonald’s Has Launched Two New Quarter Pounders And Brought Back Nacho Cheese Wedges, Police say Boris Johnson's dad Stanley will not be fined for shopping without face mask, Katie Price's son Junior showcases phenomenal singing talent as he interrupts latest YouTube video, Brigitte Nielsen looks unrecognisable with long hair in incredible throwback photo, Man Utd forced into Champions League Group of Death after Liverpool prevent Porto draw, US housing roars back despite recession, high unemployment, Best Ring deals for October 2020: Cheap deals on Ring doorbells and cameras, Penny Lancaster shares photos of 17lb weight loss after 'turning to food for comfort' during menopause, 2021 Honda Civic breaks cover in new patent photos. When The Voice debuted on BBC 1 in 2012, Will.i.am was a surprising choice for a judge. We have Tulisa to thank for Little Mix, or her “little muffins” as she liked to call them on X Factor. The fact that the judges encouraged contestants to verbally spar contributed to the overall odious flavor of the show. On some shows, the dynamic between the judges is almost as interesting to watch as the contestants. Not surprisingly, he had a knack for a good putdown, and became one of the original judges on Britain’s Got Talent, alongside Simon and Amanda Holden. with Kelly and Michael, American Idol, The One: Making a Music Star, Britain's Got Talent, Let's Dance for Comic Relief.

Kors, Garcia and Klum made the Lifetime episodes' runway shows the most entertaining part of the hour. But why is it in October?

We’ll have a new commenting experience online soon. 3. The only thing that keeps this panel from being higher on the list is Kressley, who is a nothing presence at the table. Similarly to Idol, the judge teams on America's Got Talent, and singing competitions like The Voice help make those shows popular. 16. 17. Every long-running farce needs a pantomime villain, and Louis Walsh was it. Here's your chance to vote for the best reality show judge. Now we can't imagine BGT without her. After all, when else will you be able to see Howard Stern, Heidi Klum, and Howie Mandel hang out together. 13. No offense to replacement judge Zac Posen, but when Kors departed "Runway" after its 10th season in 2012, part of the magic of the series left with him. Can you believe Mary Berry is 80? As the resident nasty judge on Strictly Come Dancing, Craig Revel Horwood’s cutting critiques and withering glances are a joy to watch. The success of The Apprentice is overwhelmingly down to Alan Sugar, whose distain for most of his show’s hopefuls results in a TV judge who is formidable and entertaining in equal measure. He moved to LA and has had great success with American Idol and So You Think You Can Dance. Sharon Osborne’s unpredictability and desire to shock led to her topping a 2013 poll to find the best reality TV judge. Comedians don’t always make great reality TV judges (just look at Michael McIntyre), but David Walliams has added a level of glee to Britain’s Got Talent. He was at his worst when paired with Murphy, whose habit of screaming quickly became grating and tiresome. 'The Masked Singer,' Season 1: Robin Thicke, Jenny McCarthy, Ken Jeong and Nicole Scherzinger. 8. The answer was yes. Part of the absolute delight of this British import, seen on PBS and Netflix, is how its prim and proper judges manage to be both fair and kind, teaching the contestants and audience about baking without ever being mean. Nicole Scherzinger was a surprisingly savvy judge on X Factor, and claimed to have put One Direction together from the motley crew of lads that hadn’t made the final cut in the solo boys category. As the lead judge on Strictly, Len Goodman gives balanced, constructive advice and doesn’t give away high scores very easily, so when he does, it’s all the more enjoyable to watch. 'RuPaul's Drag Race,' Seasons 7-11: RuPaul Charles, Michelle Visage, Ross Mathews and Carson Kressley. Thicke is too serious for a show with creepy rabbit costumes; McCarthy is described as a "pop-culture guru" despite her utter lack of credentials; Scherzinger is typically bland and ineffective; and Jeong alternates between creepy comments and self-aggrandizing spectacle. 2. Since 2005, the hardest-working man in ballroom has also been a judge on the show’s US counterpart, Dancing with the Stars. There are plenty of reality TV judges to choose from so select the judges who you think should sit atop this Ultimate List. 14. Remember Nasty Nigel Lythgoe on Popstars, the series that gave us Hear’Say, Liberty X and Darius? He didn’t grumble as he was continuously given the age group that was unlikely to win (the overs) and seemed happy to be the brunt of jokes. Watch for updates on the Microsoft News Blog. There couldn't be any other group for No. 'The Four: Battle for Stardom' Season 1: Sean Combs, DJ Khaled, Meghan Trainor and Charlie Walk. Piers is pretty divisive, and putting the outspoken broadcaster as a judge on a TV talent show was a bold move, but it's one that actually worked. Industry experience? When American Idol first hit the airwaves in 2003, viewers were curious to watch people sing for a recording contract, but it was the special chemistry between Paula Abdul, Randy Jackson, and Simon Cowell, who was also a judge on the British singing competition The X-Factor, that drew viewers back week after week. "The Voice" is unique among reality TV competition series in that the judges (called "coaches") are more important than the aspiring singers. The nation’s sweetheart has been the perfect antidote to Paul Hollywood’s brusque manner for five years on The Great British Bake Off. 10. They made perfect characters for the "Idol" story with a villain, a hero and a peacemaker (Cowell told the truth, Abdul tried to be nice, and Jackson see-sawed between them). 2022 Mercedes CLS facelift spied in AMG 53 flavour, Advent calendars for tea lovers – countdown to Christmas with a luxury brew, 'I don’t see honour in me suffering’: One family’s five-year battle for a terminally ill mother’s choice on how to die, Saint Maud is an outstanding horror movie with an unforgettable ending, The First Images From Rihanna's The Savage X Fenty Vol.2 Show Are Her And Just Wow, Ravens CB Humphrey signs five-year, $98.75m extension, Global oil prices plunge over fresh demand fears, OnePlus 8T launch event is a one-of-a-kind experience that fans will love , 35-year study hints that coronavirus immunity doesn’t last long, Instant car-ma! The Harvest Moon of 2020 rises tonight! Click through for 19 of the best reality TV judges of all time…. List RulesJudge and panel members from any reality competition game shows. Not everyone loved Jessie J on The Voice, but she definitely helped make the first series a success. Cowell in particular was able to build an entire empire based on the public persona he crafted on Idol.

She was also famous for her catchphrases, like her description of Jahmene as ‘Jah-mazing’. 9. https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/reality-tv/a800283/x-factor-judges-ranked-all-20 So two new faces will … Her quiet demeanour doesn’t mean she’s a pushover though; the last thing the contestants want to do is disappoint Mary with a soggy bottom. Ever since Fox's "American Idol" burst onto the TV scene in 2002, producers have looked for the ineffable formula for creating TV gold at the judging table, with mixed success.

The Script frontman Danny O'Donoghue put his heart and soul into the job of The Voice coach. 6. reality tv judges 1/18/2018.